Star Wars:
The Mandalorian And Grogu
Cert: 12A / 132 mins / Dir. Jon Favreau / Trailer
There's a very telling line right at the very top of 2015's The Force Awakens. After seven years away from cinema screens*1, Star Wars returned with the great Max Von Sydow's reassurance that "This will begin to make things right". It was not just in reference to the galactic map-fragment he was holding, but a (slightly ham-fisted) message to the audience that the Disney Corporation viewed the Prequel Trilogy-era as marketing anathema, and that everyone was now firmly back in safe hands. We were home! Han, Luke and Leia were back! Albeit never in the same room. Episode VII can be considered a commercial and critical success, although it's not inaccurate to say that the reception and performance of the numbered-chapters which followed and their two standalone cinematic interludes was more, well, variable. After a somewhat muddled Rise Of Skywalker closed-out a trilogy that left next to no cultural footprint, the new Lucasfilm's on-the-fly approach to filmmaking bled over into television output for Disney+, and proved just as tonally erratic. Of course the poster-boy for the small screen-era of the Galaxy Far, Far Away has been The Mandalorian, and despite that the show has its own problems, he is the hero who's been chosen for the 2026 return of Star Wars to the big screen.
So it feels notable that the first words spoken on-screen after another seven years away from the cinema come from Hemky Madera's Imperial Warlord Commander Barro, proclaiming to his subordinates and the viewership alike "I think we can all agree that things were better under the Empire". Again, it's no coincidence that this line is subtextually loaded. Even accounting for 2015-19 being ostensibly under the auspices of JJ Abrams while this phase is in the hands of Dave Filoni, the jibe is still effectively Disney-era Lucasfilm dunking on its own movies. The First-Order stuff you're nudging us to disregard was still made by you, lads. The opening line of dialogue also sets up the expectation, not unfairly, that what's about to follow is going to be pretty special...
SEASON
Timelines are deliberately sketchy under LFL's new management, but The Mandalorian And Grogu takes place after the show's third season, so probably around eleven years after the events of Return Of The Jedi. Din Djarin (Pedro Pascal) and his little green Force-wielding sidekick (himself) are still in the bounty hunting game, but have found a more stable paycheck in taking jobs from the fledgling New Republic (the authoritative face of which is presented here by Sigourney Weaver's Colonel Ward). This rolling contract involves the capture (or, if push comes to shove, elimination) of various mid-ranking Imperial Remnant warlords, before they can amass enough power to bring back the Empire. The movie opens James Bond / Indiana Jones style with Mando in the middle of snagging the aforementioned Barro, prior to being assigned the job of tracking the mysterious General Coin on a trail which will take him deep into Hutt space...
So it's been long established that Disney wanted to move away from the 'Episode' numbering system of cinematic installments (and with fair reason given their hopping around the timeline in each 'non-Skywalker-saga' project), but as well as the omissions of regular features we'd expect here (no lightsabers, no Artoo and Threepio*2 , no Wilhelm Scream), this is also the first branded Star Wars movie to open without the 'A Long Time Ago, In A Galaxy Far, Far Away...' title card, the first to feature cast and production names in the opening credits, and the first to end without sweeping into John Williams' closing score. It's perhaps also worth noting that the aqua-green 'swoosh' branding used across the film's marketing material is nowhere to be seen in the film itself, opting instead for a flat, two-colour title card of the established Mandalorian-logo/font. Progress is one thing, but it's unclear whether moving forward by becoming more 'ordinary' will prove to be a winning strategy for the franchise.
And that question of identity extends well past the title sequence.
The final screenplay here is very clearly several episodic storylines taped together, and the flow of the movie suffers as a result. 2008's The Clone Wars cinematic outing was also plagued by this of course, but at least in the days of network TV those episodes were all the same length. True to Mandalorian TV-form, each of these strands is 'as long as it needs to be', which means the overall pacing is at best baffling and at worst incoherent.
EVIL
As much as tMAG doesn't rely too heavily on the TV show's own established continuity (the price of entry is surprisingly low, you can watch this having only seen the first season), it was never going to be truly Standalone™, coming as it does after 15½ hours of its televisual predecessor's run-time. The fact that the film doesn't even try to expand on those previous events or leave the timeline any real consequence*3 other than finally giving Mando another ship he can use to do his actual job in*4 is - admittedly - a weightier burden. Outside of the eponymous pairing very few faces from the small-screen return here, whereas new faces pop up intermittently throughout the run-time thanks to the sequential format. Worse, Star Wars' tradition for clearly and verbally naming its major players in the first act is a coin-toss affair. Zeb Orellios from the Rebels animated series had a background cameo in the TV show but shows up here as a fairly major supporting character, yet his name is only muttered twice in the script where it's lost in the wall of noise. Likewise, iconic Clone Wars bounty hunter Embo features heavily in the movie's mid-section (I can't say 'second act', that's not how this is made) and is effectively nameless on-screen (again, it's said once among longer dialogue, and I only know that because I went out of my way to attend a subtitled screening).
The screenplay does occasionally try to lean into genuine emotion between the two lead characters, but usually undercuts itself with whimsy, stoicism or the fact that one of them is wearing a helmet over his facial expression (and let's face it Pascal is no expressive mime-artist) and the other is a puppet; a nicely expressive puppet for the story's broader strokes, but without Yoda's wrinkles (and size), Grogu's range is, shall we say, limited.
Pascal puts in a reasonable enough turn as Djarin overall, of course. By this point he knows how to play the part, and in the majority of his scenes here he's interacting with effects-work, so the character's trademark stand-offishness works perfectly well. On first viewing though, I found Sigourney Weaver's Colonel Ward to be equally stilted, even more than the character's rank and position suggesting she might be. The next time round, however, I noticed that Weaver's delivery is actually channelling Carrie Fisher's Leia in the Sequel Trilogy films, and the thought occurred that had things panned out differently in our own timeline, it might have been General Organa we saw handing out the 'Gulf War' cards.
DENVER
In fairness, while the film doesn't do much to develop its own cast, it is considerably more interested in playing with the wider toybox.
Despite that opening line as above, there is a reasonable smattering of Sequel Trilogy referencing here (the Anzellans in particular, as well as droid archetypes from across the 2015-19 films), an Original Trilogy-heavy opening sequence (with bonus INT-4 Mini-Rig for those of a certain age) and Prequel Trilogy vibes coming from adapted antique battle droids and their STAP-riders. With Clone Wars supervising-director Dave Filoni now in the big chair at Lucasfilm it's perhaps no surprise that the animated series perhaps has the biggest external influence, with that bounty hunter and his amazing hat doing his best to steal any remaining scenes not nabbed by Jabba's boy Rotta The Hutt (who is, of course, His Own Man™), both characters originally created on his watch. It can't be escaped, however, that Mr Filoni seems to think his cameo appearances are comparable to those of Alfred Hitchcock, when they are instead absolutely of the same calibre as M. Knight Shyamalan's...
Visually, the movie lands in a similarly mixed place.
When the action is taking place outdoors (thankfully often) cinematographer David Klein's visuals are dense and richly detailed (even if they do have that slightly muted, artificial hum brought about by filming on a soundstage), but a lot of the interior scenes are ludicrously dark. And as you'd expect, this problem is only exacerbated through a pair of 3D glasses*5. 2018's Solo had the excuse of removing detail to try and preserve budget on a production which required 80% reshoots, but tMAG should be under no such restrictions. In more than a few of the melee-fight scenes it's difficult to tell what's actually happening (made worse in the life-sized Dejarik battle, where watching CGI berserker-creatures clobbering other CGI berserker-creatures is, I'm afraid, terminally uninteresting*6). And if the clarity can't be picked out on a cinema-sized screen in blackout-conditions, good luck watching this on Disney+ in your living room.
And while I'm here and complaining about things on a slightly unfair technical level, the Imperial Officers of the Original Trilogy had those Hugo-Boss-inspired*7, razor-sharp uniforms and received-pronunciation accents (that's Radio 4 Continuity Announcer to you), largely as a result of trained Shakespearean actors from RADA and the Royal Central School of Speech and Acting. While Commander Barro's informal fur-collar can be explained by his snowy surroundings and his diction at least retains force and authority, the Empire now seems whittled down to the point where we get General Coin, a bald bloke in a grey tweed sports-jacket who looks and speaks like a mid-tier gang boss from Bermondsey. I am still genuinely tickled at how some Americans (which in this case appears to be the entire production and editing staff at Lucasfilm) have an absolute tin-ear for the British accent and its myriad regional implications. No wonder we didn't see Coin during the Original Trilogy; Ozzel, Jerjerrod and Veers would have had him emptying the bins...
TERRITORY
Fortunately, where the film really wants to succeed, it generally does. Ludwig Göransson's score romps the whole thing along nicely (with the slightest dusting of John Williams), even if the soundtrack never feels like it does more than it needs to. The scope and effects work is over-and-above what you'd expect of a TV show (Season Two's krayt dragon notwithstanding), but the overall structure and lasting effect is not. This wasn't made to be 'more than' its small screen sibling, just as an extra story in another medium. Which feels weird given that we've had The Mandalorian for well over half a decade, and the traditional expanded-universe storytelling of comics, novels and video games surrounding it is nowhere to be seen.
In its top-down form, The Mandalorian And Grogu is essentially a series of precariously threaded fight-sequences. Luckily, these fight sequences are where the film positively shines, with Djarin despatching droids and Stormtroopers alike with the adrenaline-glee of an eight year old wired on Haribo and flipping over their Kenner action figures. This really is Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni playing with their toys (and I do not mean this as a criticism).
So does the film show any development of Mandalorian-lore and Din Djarin's evolving place in both honouring his past and forging his people's future, while caring for a youngling who's finding his way between two traditionally-opposing ancient cultures? Nope. Does the film expand upon the mechanisms of the New Republic in its work to rebuild trust and hope in the aftermath of the Galactic Empire? Nope. But is this at least a rounded, satisfying adventure movie designed to appeal to a mainstream cinema audience? Well what do you think? Of course it's not.
Okay, is The Mandalorian And Grogu a fairly undemanding and uncontroversial fandom tickbox exercise which bolts-on perfectly to a TV series which has been - to be fair - absolutely all over the place? Yes, yes it is. Star Wars is well past the era of 'event-cinema' whether we like that or not (to be fair, event-cinema might be well past the era of event-cinema), and in 2026 we have to take the fun where we can find it.
I had enormous fun with this movie.
This is the way.
Okay, it's "a" way...

(Y'see, I'm not even sure if The Mandalorian And Grogu should get any star-rating at all. I automatically assign 7 because it's Star Wars and that's my thing, but this is not a full-marks Star Wars movie. It's arguably not a movie at all. But it's still more way satisfying to watch and ponder-over than The Rise Of Skywalker, and that got full marks from me, so what can you do?)
*1 Don't @ me. Yes 2005's Revenge Of The Sith was a decade before 2015's The Force Awakens, but The Clone Wars movie landed at cinemas in 2008, seven years before TFA. Yes, of course that counts. [ BACK ]
*2 There is a moment in the opening titles at the New Republic base on Adelphi (which I swear to god looks like it's two doors down from Tony Stark's mansion) where an R2-unit is being loaded into an X-Wing fighter, and the way it's presented - with the droid right in the middle of the frame, visually uninterupted over a lingering shot - seems to suggest that perhaps this is a cameo from our favourite Astromech. But then, Artoo will be with Luke at this point in the timeline, and he's nowhere to be seen here. This would also be a level of subtlety completely not in keeping with the movie's other cameo appearances, so forget I said anything. But if Dave Filoni turns up on the commentary track saying that's R-D2, you read it here first. [ BACK ]
*3 Okay, two members of Moff Gideon's Shadow Council are removed from the frame here, but after a blink-and-you'll-miss-it introduction one episode before the end of Mandalorian Season Three they were hardly holding the plot together. Potentially more galactic fallout comes from the deaths of the Hutt-twins, but they weren't strictly characters from the Mandalorian series anyway, so it's debatable when their loss will be revisited. [ BACK ]
*4 Yeah I'm going to say it again, they had to give Mando another Razor Crest because he can't be a bounty hunter in an N1 Starfighter with no storage facilities. Why do you think the first mission we see him completing with that ship involves him decapitating someone and bringing just their head back? Because the guy can't bring back any target which doesn't fit into a small duffel-bag. The N1 was a ridiculous idea and he should have never picked up the keys for it. [ BACK ]
*5 Because of course I also went to see this in 3D. More out of novelty than anything else, admittedly. Way back in the dim and distant past of 2019, I recall actually having to travel to another town to watch The Rise Of Skywalker in three dimensions, because my local multiplex was only screening it in two. Even back then it appeared the entire industry and audiences alike had given up on the fad, so I have no idea why stereoscopy is rearing its head again now. For what it's worth, the 3D conversion of Mandalorian is 'basically fine'. It doesn't need the 3D (live-action flicks rarely do), and for the most part it's a forgettable add-on which also makes the film's darker scenes even more problematic. [ BACK ]
*6 No, seriously. Dejarik is presented in A New Hope (and again in The Force Awakens) as the Star Wars version of chess on a round board. The holographic monsters represent pieces which have their own limited and unique movements and powers, resulting in a strategic game that requires both intelligence and experience to play - hence it being so difficult to win against a droid. The "Dejarik match" in The Mandalorian And Grogu seems to involve releasing the real-world counterparts into a circular arena which is at least painted like a Dejarik board, whereby they all just randomly attack each other on account of being wild animals. THAT'S NOT WHAT CHESS IS, IS IT? IF YOU DID LIFE-SIZE GIANT CHESS WITH PEOPLE IN COSTUMES, THERE'D STILL BE RULES. THEY WOULDN'T ALL JUST START STABBING EACH OTHER AND SHOUTING "YES, THIS IS THE CHESS". ffs... [ BACK ]
*7 You know what I mean by that. [ BACK ]
DISCLAIMERS:
• ^^^ That's dry, British humour, and most likely sarcasm or facetiousness.
• Yen's blog contains harsh language and even harsher notions of propriety. Reader discretion is advised.
• This is a personal blog. The views and opinions expressed here represent my own thoughts (at the time of writing) and not those of the people, institutions or organisations that I may or may not be related with unless stated explicitly.



